Mag tapes used to be a better alternative due to size. Depending on the size of your company disk backup can cost more money though. One veeam solution backup up all virtual machines to a seperate disk system staging it to tape and a traditional symantec backup exec backup up user files and application data directly to tape. Media that can be securely erased includes both hard drives that use perpendicular and longitudinal recording techniques, including 5000 oersteds and all common backup tapes. Diffrence between backup to tape and file to tape veeam. However, if we again consider ssd disk drives the typical sequential write speeds are closer to 280 mbs.
What is the difference between a tape drive and a hard. As data protection becomes a growing part of the it budget, it seems like every technology that records data wants to claim primacy and indispensability. While diskbased backups certainly hold many strengths, there are still strong use cases for tape as a backup medium in modern enterprise datacenters. With a tape, you have to fastforward or reverse to get to any particular point on the tape. In fact, this is one of the oldest default backup plans in the office today. With tape, a reasonable backup schedule would mean at least 1 full backup per week, plus nightly incremental backups. Vm backup to disk is the primary storage medium used by todays modern data protection solutions. This is hardly a surprising conclusion from a provider of. As i understand backup exec is a dead product not running os later than windows 2008r2 so i would like to find an updated solution to replace backup. The next con of tape versus disk in backup is normally reliability.
There can, however, be reliability and security concerns with backups to tape. A quick comparison of the advantages of various backup media types including digital linear tape, hard disks, and solid state drives. Tape capacity is limited only by available shelf space, but disk backup requires no interaction. Disk backups are widely used and can be supplemented by methods such as tape or cloud backup for archiving or disaster recovery dr. Coinciding with the tape drive technology enhancements, hard disks continued to improve, and it wasnt long before the large removable disk packs were completely replaced by sealed winchester fixed drives. The complete strategy of veeam is made for disk backup. If you are keen on avoiding using tape, then my recommendation would be to consider cloud for data archival.
As far as backup and recovery goes, the extreme differences in functionality between tape and disk as well as the shrinking difference in cost is pushing many people towards disk and the. It supports pcs, servers, and even includes support of 6 different hypervisors with agentless and agentbased backup. Mar 31, 2010 the tape assessment program is able to search old tape libraries for a specific file, or files, and once those files are found, it can extract them without having to use the original backup software that was used to create those files. Best modern disk to tape backup solution spiceworks. Reviewing the most popular business backup solutions. Tape lto, disk hddssd, and the cloud whats part of your backup plan. Nov 20, 2017 disk based backup generally speaking, disk based backup is significantly quicker and more reliable for data restoration than tape based backup. In most cases write speed increases of 100200% can be obtained simply by changing the maximum block size written to tape from the software default usually 64kb to 1mb.
Jan 27, 2011 backup virtualization abstracts the backup storage hardware from the backup software enabling the backup software to write and read data from a single virtual storage device. On the other hands, the magnetic disk is used as a secondary storage in modern computers the magnetic disk has several platters arranged one above the other to form a cylinder, and each platter has a readwrite head that. This article will take a look at the step by step procedures of backing up a hard disk drive with the aomei backupper hard drive backup software. Disk backup, or diskbased backup, is a data backup and recovery method that backs data up to hard disk storage.
Is it reasonable to assume that rotated external drives are adequate for backing up data reliably. Since i am comparing tape backup to disk drive backup the scenario for this article is a small business that handles lots of data. Tape backup is giving way to disk as a backup target, but tape still has numerous benefits that mean it is likely to be with us for a long time yet. Choose the right software application selection will play a major role in the completeness of your companys backups, the time spent managing them and the thoroughness of any data recovery efforts. Disk backups eliminate the time it takes to mount a tape. Mar 30, 2020 easeus todo backup free has lots of bases covered. Mar 03, 2017 cost comparisons have been made between tape media and hard disk drives.
Read more to learn about the pros and cons of tape vs cloud backup. Tape backup became far cheaper than disk, and also offered more flexibility. Here are a few best practices that should help your business make a successful move toward disk to disk to tape backup. It can perform disktodisk cloning, create vhd or vhdx image files, restore individual files from image backups, perform bare metal restore using the iperius recovery environment media, convert physical machines to virtual machines and immediately start a backup as a vm on hyper v. Basically this means backing up a local disk resource to remote hard drives physically connected to a remote machine. The same limitations also apply to the spindles and platens of a typical hard disk as they rotate inside the disk enclosure. A look at the modern data storage industry can make your head spin. The old adage of time is money couldnt be more accurate, particularly when determining the value of storing and recovering data. One of the most important things to consider when it comes to disk backup, is that it isnt as reliable as backup tape. If you are honest, tape backup in veeam backup and replication is much less usable, than disk backup. It can also back up entire systems, restore to dissimilar hardware, and includes storage deduplication and wan optimization. Jan 17, 2017 the basic difference between magnetic tape and magnetic disk is that magnetic tape is used for backups whereas, magnetic disk are used as secondary storage.
The two most common forms of data storage remain, at this point, tape backup and hard drive or disk backup. Similarly, restoration from disk is a relatively efficient process. An optimally balanced backup strategy is to store the latest backup to online disk for fast, reliable restores, while also copying the disk based backups to low cost tape for longterm storage and offsite removal. You might be surprised because the cloud is as new a backup location as ssd. The hard disk platter is then polished to mirrortype smoothness. Easeus todo backup also allows changing the file compression of a backup, limiting the backup speed and priority, wiping a disk, backing up an android device, preserving security settings during a backup, splitting an archive into a smaller section, password protecting a backup, and scheduling a backup on a onetime, daily, weekly, or monthly. Despite the many advantages of disk storage for backing up data, shipments of tape storage keep growing because for some jobs, tape is best. Easeus todo backup server is the perfect tape backup software. Long time ago before we used backup to disk there was a 23 tape set generated every week. Data backup hard disk drives or tapes, which is best for your business. Pros and cons of tape vs cloud backup envisionit solutions. While the amount of data storage available through tape.
As of 2011, the highest capacity tape cartridges t0c can store 5 tb of uncompressed data source wikipedia, while hard drives have followed kryders law much like moores law and doubled areal density every two to four years putting disk drive capacity currently somewhere around 4 tb. Let us discuss some more differences between magnetic tape and magnetic disk with the help of comparison chart shown below. On a hard disk, you can move to any point on the surface of the disk almost instantly. The backup war exposed the debate over whether disk or tape is the better solution for backup has been going on for some time now, and it seems the answer you get typically. The tape assessment program is able to search old tape libraries for a specific file, or files, and once those files are found, it can extract them without having to use the original backup software that was used to create those files. It is then a simple matter to set up a network backup where every server is. Disk for backup and data recovery trusted data solutions. And, as i can see, tape backup has got no priority in veeam software development. Holding them back from doing this is the common belief that disks cant match the attributes of tapes. Backups become even more tedious especially when one deploys a wrong tool. And you wont be able to put everything on a single tape, so youll have to swap them out a couple of times to do a single backup. Mar 21, 2012 storagepipe online backup and disaster recovery 9,631 views 7. Key differences between magnetic tape and magnetic disk. While disk is less fussy about the throughput of your backup systems and is.
Cost comparisons have been made between tape media and hard disk drives. Disk and tape each have their storage strengths and weaknesses. However, the lto program has found that at less than one cent per gb, lto7 tape is significantly less expensive than a. Tape is seen by many as slow and inflexible whereas disk based systems give a convenient, easy to operate, backup system with the ability to add on extra features such as single instance storage and deduplication that require a dynamic filing system. Backing up data can mean different things to it and business users. Mar 14, 2010 debugging the 1959 ibm 729 vacuum column tape drive at the computer history museum duration. The datagauss lg max is the most powerful, compact, continuous degausser for hard drives and backup tapes in the vs security products range. Add to this the important point that a tape readwrite is a linear process requiring the tape to move to a specific point before data can be written or read while disks allow for immediate readwrite functionality and it seems again that hard disks are the longterm winner. Factors to consider when switching from tape to disk based backup are your overall disaster recovery strategy and performance. Instead of writing from disk such as your hard drives or servers to a tape, a disktodisk backup is simply a more efficient method of data transfer. Still, a clear winner has emerged for longterm data backup and archiving. But cloud provides certain advantages over disk or even tape that are hard to ignore. Some have argued that tape storage is twice the cost per gigabyte gb of sata hdd storagecomparing the raw media costs of a tape cartridge to an hdd.
We also explain how using the right backup software can mitigate the disadvantage of both tape and disk, to give you better results. Depending on how much data is being backed up fullincremental, id say use the tape to backup critical daytoday business operations files, emails, whatever and keep rotating that tape offsite. Tape contains a level 0 backup of the whole database from february 1, incremental level 1 backups for each day from monday through the present day, and any archived redo logs for the whole week. A few words about hardware compression in a backup with tape drives. With diskbased solutions, the enterprise only needs to perform one full backup every 4 weeks, with nightly incremental backups in between. Architecturally tape drives are sequential storage, meaning that if you need to access some data at the end of the tape you needed to seek to the end and retrieve it.
The truth is that most it managers are anxious to replace their tape drives and cartridges within their data centers with hard disk drives. A look at advantages and disadvantages as well as use cases of performing backup to tape vs. Tape backup vs external hard drive anandtech forums. A typical 7200 rpm hard drive might have write speeds around mbs.
J unitrends absolutely sells disk based archiving and offers tape based archiving. Disk versus tape technology understanding the facts. To a business user, a backup may imply no loss of data, and nearly instantaneous data recovery. We have a 7year data retention schedule, so perhaps we could just use hard drives and shudder windows backup. But with the crops of hard drive backup software on the market, it becomes a little easier and faster to deal with. Iperius is a powerful software to clone the hard disk. Disk drive technology, however, wasnt just standing still. This chapter presents in detail several disk only and disk and tape based backup strategies that make effective use of rman, incrementally updated backups, and the flash recovery area. Seagate 10gb20gb uncompressedcompress travan tape drive bundled with backup exec software.
Businesses generally turn to one of three options to replace tape backup. Backup to tape jobs allow you to archive full backups or forward incremental backup chains stored on disk files to tape jobs allow you to archive files from any microsoft windows or linux server connected to the veeam backup server or from a shared folder accessible by. Which is better backup media magnetic tape or hard drive. In recent years, there has been a significant shift toward diskbased backup in terms of media used as targets by data protection solutions. Tape has a longer shelf life than a raid array used in diskbased backup, though that lends itself more to archiving purposes. In this post, we weigh the advantages of vm backup to tape and disk. Read on to find out how tape and disk can work handinhand to complete the backup puzzle and create a more comprehensive solution than could be obtained by just using one method or the other. The magnetic tapes are used for backups and the storage of the data that may be less frequently used. Oracle continues to promote the open lto tape format, which is supported by products from ibm, hpe, quantum, and spectralogic.
Every business is different whether in architecture or budget. Instead of writing from disk such as your hard drives or servers to a tape, a disk to disk backup is simply a more efficient method of data transfer. A suitable tape drive is going to be a couple grand. It can back up your files and data to tape directly, as well as via disk to disk to tape. Best practices for disktodisktotape backup biztech. It can support backing up data or system state to tape which is typically used for offline, archival data storage. Diskbased backup provides fast backup and restore operations for data changed within the past 90. From a variety of hard drives, efficient disk arrays, magnetic tapes, conventional or emulated tape libraries to such miracles of modern technology like rdx formats.
Then there is the current low cost of hard disks, a 5tb disk does not cost that much more than a 5tb lto 6 tape, and the tape capacity is based. Tape still has a very good lifespan and storage capacity and while hddsnas devices are much faster and readily available, tape s main advantage. Tape backup vs disk backup secure data recovery services. Tape lto, disk hdd ssd, and the cloud whats part of your backup plan. As a result, the best attributes of each platform can be leveraged.
Disktodisktotape d2d2t is an approach to computer storage backup and archiving in which data is initially copied to backup storage on a disk storage system and then periodically copied again to a tape storage system. Meanwhile, diskbased backup offers the promise of speedy. For me and my clients, thats usually reason enough to choose a hard disk based backup when theres lots of data involved and limited funds. Tape is still the cheapest backup media and during actual backup is the quickest method, as long as you have everything set up correctly. Diskbased backup generally speaking, diskbased backup is significantly quicker and more reliable for data restoration than tapebased backup. When hdds were still measured in mb it was a no brainer when you wanted gbs of storage tapes were your only alternative. Debugging the 1959 ibm 729 vacuum column tape drive at the computer history museum duration. This is one of the reasons why i wrote this article. Tape is an established backup target, but the cost of disk is falling. This is hardly a surprising conclusion from a provider of offsite tape archive services. This is 24 4tb disk drives being added to the vault every year. In a cassette tape deck, the readwrite head touches. Unlike tape, which stores data sequentially, disk has the advantage of random access storage, which greatly increases data access and reduces restore times, particularly when restoring individual files or small amounts of data. Then came cddvd and later br, not to mention hdds became cheap and l.
1295 785 734 269 615 1297 738 1035 1039 1457 830 1414 1515 138 476 626 995 768 395 741 69 1637 1049 1057 196 886 256 1536 335 958 964 1237 1573 1104 1034 811 308 480 527 1352 562 490 243 15